Umut

inandırıcılığı aşırı düşük. karakterlerin reaksiyonları, yaşanan olaylar. karakterin başına aynı günlerde 100 tane bela gelmesi vs. hatta ben filmin stil olarak bisiklet hırsızları'ndan da çalıntıya yakın olduğunu düşünüyorum. sanatsal olarak da aşırı bir değeri yok. filmin tek düzgün yanı şu: kalbinin attığı yer ve amatörlüğüne rağmen görüntü yönetimi. Nerede "yol" nerede bu film. lütfen arkadaşlar puanlarınızı götten vermeyin.

Interesting, low-key drama mixes elements of BICYCLE THIEVES and TREASURE OF SIERRA MADRE; lacks the spit and polish that might elevate it to loftier company, but the rough edges give it an energy and vitality that almost compensate - worthwhile as an insight and window into living in poverty in Turkey, with some fine, naturalistic performances by its cast.

A bit naive and obstinately declarative, verbally iterating the drama at all times, but still kind of warm and charming. The photography grabbed me most. From a technical standpoint it's full of staging, lighting and editing errors, but cinematographer Kaya Ererez's framing and compositions are truly inspired. It really shows what the natural gift for visual aesthetic can do without need for extravagant locations, expensive art design or studio effects. The film comes off as a very rough gem.

Plot 13/20 Fiction 14/20 Casting/Acting 16/20 Worldbuilding 16/20 Entertainment 14/20

And this, my friends, is why I am atheist.

Remembered me an Iranian Movie "The Cow", but this movie is more intricate and complex. It wasn't an odd sense when you see these elements in your everyday life and the integration of culture between us made the movie absolutely sensible. The last part of the movie can be less. It was a little jarring.

The ending is perhaps a bit much, or maybe the build up is a bit lacking, but the film's thematic through-line is very strong and overall very well executed.

italyanlarin bisiklet hirsizlari varsa bizim de "umut" filmimiz var dedirtti mubarek.

a significant flick in turkish and world cinema history. it's quite simply a masterpiece.