Kelebegin Rüyasi

bugunleride gorduk; turk sinemasi "decent" gise filmleri uretebiliyor, yasasin! - iki sairin hayati da olsa bu kadar fazla ic ses ile siir okunmaz bir filmde. yilmaz erdogan tarafindan siir sevgisi adina katledilmis bir film mevcut. +herseye ragmen standartlari bir nebze yakalamis film. türk gisesinin önünü acabilecegini düsünüyorum. yukarida yaptigim cok dis ses elestirisi ise muhtemelen kotu siiri cok fazla seven yurdum insanimiz tarafindan yol, su ve elektrik olarak iade edilecektir.

Decent enough. It's good to see that with some money, we can also make decent historical Turkish movies about our past. Erdoğan's love for poetry can be experienced throughout the whole movie, and the leads give good performances. Though I found the cinematography trying to achieve too much. Simplicity would've helped more.

This is a very good timepiece (1940s). The director is a renowned poet and the idea of constructing a movie around poems is a great one. I'm not a big fan of poetry so maybe you are into poetry you might enjoy it even more (though some of it can get lost in translation). The strongest point of the movie was its ability to catch very intimate moments. I also enjoy the acting style of Tatlitug, I think that he is a world class actor and I hope that he will get more opportunities in the future.

Plot 8/20 Fiction 11/20 Casting/Acting 13/20 Worldbuilding 14/20 Entertainment 10/20

Pretty good production value for a Turkish movie, but otherwise all the depth and interest of your average mainstream movie.

Whoever told Erdoğan that being an average actor, terrible poetry-loving poet and inexplicably popular figure makes you a good director, should take his word back. If he told this to himself, I am afraid there is nothing we could do but to avoid his movies.

Tokalaşmakla verem bulaşmaz, bulaşsa bulaşsa sevgi bulaşır o da zamanla geçer

* Casting, Acting : 6 * Script : 5.5 * Directing, Aura : 6 * Ease of Viewing : 7.5 * Naked Eye : 6

Çekimleri Türk sinemasında bir adım olabilecek türden.

Vizontele I'den sonra Yılmaz Erdoğan'ın ikinci güzel işi diyebilirim. Piyasaya yönelik film çekip, cebini doldurma imkanı varken, şiirle ve şairlerle uğraşıp, onları ömründe şiir okumamış halka tanıtması gerçekten kutlanılacak bir davranış, tüm ekibin ellerine sağlık. Nuri Bilge ve Ghobadi ile o kadar çalıştıktan sonra böyle güzel bir iş de boşuna çıkmamı&

Turk sinemasinin medar-i iftihari.